Should You Put Landscape Fabric Under Mulch

Alright, gather 'round, folks. I've got a tale to tell about something that's been causing quite the ruckus in gardens worldwide. It's a tale of two fabrics - landscape fabric and mulch. Now, don't go rolling your eyes, this is gonna be a hoot, I promise.

Meet the Fabrics

First, let me introduce you to our players. Landscape fabric, or 'landscaping's answer to Spanx', as I like to call it, is that stuff that looks like a giant, greenish, stretchy net. It's made of synthetic materials, like plastic or polyester, and it's got one job: to keep weeds at bay.

Then there's mulch. Oh, mulch. The original garden superstar. It's made from all sorts of things - wood chips, straw, even old coffee grounds. It's like the garden's version of a cozy blanket, keeping the soil warm and moist, and looking darn good while doing it.

So, Should They Get a Room Together?

Now, here's where things get interesting. Some folks say, "Heck yeah, they should be together! Mulch on top, fabric on the bottom, like a weird, green sandwich." Others say, "No way, Jose! They're like oil and water, or, you know, Republicans and Democrats. They just don't mix."

So, who's right? Well, let's dive in and find out.

Team 'Together Forever'

Alright, let's hear from the 'together forever' crowd. Their main argument is that landscape fabric stops weeds from growing up through your mulch. And, boy, do they have a point. Weeds are like the garden's version of a bad ex - they just won't stay away. But with fabric, it's like they're trapped in a never-ending episode of 'Groundhog Day', unable to break through.

Another perk is that fabric helps retain moisture. It's like a tiny, invisible umbrella for your plants, keeping them hydrated even when it's as dry as the Sahara out there. Plus, it helps regulate soil temperature, keeping things nice and toasty in the winter and cool in the summer.

Landscape Fabric Under Mulch Landscape Fabric For Weeds Or No? I Have

But here's where things get a bit... well, gross. See, that fabric that's so great at keeping moisture in? It's also great at keeping moisture in. And that can lead to some serious waterlogging, which is about as good for plants as a snowcone in a blizzard.

Oh, and get this - some studies have shown that fabric can actually increase weed growth in the long run. I know, right? It's like the garden's version of a horror movie twist. But here's the thing - fabric can create a perfect little greenhouse effect, warming up the soil and making it a weed paradise.

Team 'Oil and Water'

Now, let's hear from the 'oil and water' crowd. Their main beef is that fabric can suffocate your soil. You see, soil needs air to breathe, just like us humans. And when you lay down a big ol' sheet of fabric, it's like putting a giant, plastic bag over your soil's head. Not great for plant health, folks.

Another issue is that fabric can prevent beneficial nutrients and organic matter from getting into your soil. It's like having a garden full of plants that can't eat their veggies. And we all know how cranky we get when we're hungry.

But here's where things get interesting - mulch can actually improve soil health. It breaks down over time, adding organic matter to your soil and making it richer and more fertile. Plus, it helps suppress weeds, keeps the soil cool, and retains moisture. It's like the garden's version of a supermodel - it does it all.

Landscape Fabric Under Rock Or Not at Laura Strong blog

So, What's a Gardener to Do?

Alright, so we've heard from both sides. But what's the verdict? Should you put landscape fabric under mulch, or should you give it the old heave-ho?

Well, here's my two cents. If you're dealing with a serious weed problem, and you've got the time and money to invest in fabric, then go for it. But if you're looking for a more natural, long-term solution, then mulch is your friend. It might take a bit longer to work, but it's better for your soil in the long run.

And hey, if you're feeling really adventurous, you could always try a combination. Lay down a thin layer of fabric to keep the really persistent weeds at bay, then cover it with a thick layer of mulch. It's like the garden's version of a compromise - everyone's a little bit happy.

But remember, folks, gardening is all about trial and error. What works for one garden might not work for another. So, don't be afraid to get out there, get your hands dirty, and see what works best for you.

And there you have it - the great landscape fabric debate. I hope I've given you some food for thought, and maybe even a laugh or two. Now, who's ready for another round of coffee?